Features

Help, My Parents Posted on My Facebook Wall

The social networking site once deemed too cool for parents is now littered with them, but it's not just the kids who are rolling their eyes.


by Joanna Stern
11/19/2007
 
Email Article print this story
Sixteen-year-old Ashley M. of St. Louis was sick of adults barging in on what was once her exclusive virtual hangout. So when her mom's friends and her friends' parents started creating Facebook profiles, she decided to take matters into her own hands. She created a group called "Adults NEED to stay off Facebook!" The group, which now has more than 500 members, regularly vents its frustrations online. And all across Facebook, groups like "If You Have a Child You Shouldn't Have Facebook" and "Facebook Should Not Allow Adults to Join!!!" have seen growing membership rates.
 
In September 2006, Facebook--formerly an exclusive online club for college kids and high schoolers--opened itself to the entire Web population. The Facebook blog post from September 26, 2006, described the expansion: "This includes your friends who graduated pre-Facebook (yes, there was such a time), [and] your friends who don't have school or work e-mail addresses. Now you can all connect." According to a May 2007 comScore survey, 10.4 million Facebook visitors are now 35 or older. Facebook wasn't the first to venture into mature social networking (see MySpace and LinkedIn), but the graying of this service in particular has a lot of kids saying GAL. If you don't know that means "get a life," you might want to do some homework before diving in.

No Adults Allowed
"When I first joined Facebook, you had to be a college student to join. And it was great, it was special, it gave us our own little spot on the Web," said Jonathon Defaria, a student at the University of Central Florida. But with adult members now on the site, "it loses its specialness and becomes MySpace with a different name. It's no longer limited to a semi-tight knit network of your college friends across the world; now it's someone's nosy parents."
 
But that's not stopping people like Debbie Wrixon, a 38-year-old insurance underwriter from Toronto, from joining the site. Wrixon was yearning for younger days--ones filled with rotary phones, Jimi Hendrix, 33 1/3 LPs, and drive-in movies. Although it was an age that preceded the Internet, she found others on Facebook who wanted to share memories of the 1960s and 1970s. Nevermind that the service's core members, like Ashley and Jonathon, only know about this era through reruns of The Wonder Years. Wrixon's Facebook group, entitled "Unlike 99.99% of the Facebook population, I was born in the 60s," had more than 2,100 members as of press time.   
 
Uninterested in social networking sites for mothers only, such as cafemom.com, Cathy DeCenzo, 54, joined Facebook to network with her friends and people in the Web design industry. "My intent was not to embarrass my kids, but it did," said DeCenzo. "And unfortunately it became another intrusion by adults into 'their world.'" DeCenzo's 20-year-old daughter has reacted by not allowing her mother to see her profile page. Still, Cathy hopes her daughter will allow her into her network, promising that "whatever I see on on Facebook stays on Facebook."
 
Hall Ramirez, a 19-year-old sophomore at California Institute of the Arts, isn't a member of one of the anti-adults-on-Facebook clubs, but he's nevertheless concerned about the infiltration of adults. Many are popping up in his groups, and some of his friends' parents are joining the site. "I think it's embarrassing for a parent to join in, because it's really not their game to play," he said. "There's a lot of adolescent 'growing up' stuff going on Facebook that a parent is really not supposed to see."
 
 John M. Grohol, a social psychologist who publishes Psychcentral.com, told us that sites like Facebook help today's youth feel like there's a place that accepts them for who they are right now, as opposed to five years from now. If parents keep on registering in large numbers, however, their kids may feel compelled to find a new virtual hangout. "It won't be long before youth find a new technology, a new way of interacting, or a new twist on social networking that they can call their own," said Grohol. "At least for a little while."

Making New Friends, Keeping Up with the Old
Reading Donna Barsalou's wall posts (Facebook's term for forum  entries), you might think she had gone back to school with the youthful Facebook crowd to major in online lingo. "I am certainly older than the majority of users on Facebook," said the 55-year-old recreation therapist in a Facebook messaging chat. "My daughter, who is 27 years old, told me about Facebook, and being someone who is not willing to be left behind in today's technology, I jumped right in and set up my own profile."
 
Like many other Facebook newbies, Barsalou was attracted to the potential of finding people from her past with whom she had lost touch. "I am so excited to say I found and reconnected with a few of my childhood friends. We were army brats. The last time I had spoken to any of them was in 1968 when I moved away."
 
Reuniting is only part of the appeal of social networking sites. Nathan Mather, a 28-year-old attorney from New Jersey who started using Facebook nearly two years ago, has made a lot of new friends. He started the "Unlike 99.99% of the Facebook population, I was born in the 70s" group, which now has more than 104,000 members. "I wouldn't call all of them my good friends, but I've met plenty of 'Facebook friends' over the past year," he said.
 
Not for Me
For some, the transparency and the breakdown of privacy inherent in social networking makes it a turn-off. "I consider myself an open person with a self-deprecating sense of humor," said Karen Thomas, a 53-year-old mother who lives in Massachusetts. "But it's just the concept of putting it all out there for anyone to know. I guess I see it as pathetic in some ways--self-value through how many 'friends' or 'pokes' one gets," said Thomas. For the uninitiated, a 'poke' is Facebook's non-sexual term for a way to interact with your friends.
 
Thomas admits having signed into her son's Facebook account to check out who she might know on the site, but she hasn't had the desire to create her own account and log in day after day. She's part of the 52 percent of online adults who don't participate at all in social computing activities. Matt Solomon, 31, says it's not the way he wants to communicate. "I think that most of the people on these sites are looking for one thing: attention. The people I care about right now know how to get in touch with me."
 
Others cite the issue of how closely these sites are now monitored by prospective and current employers, especially now that Facebook has opened parts of everyone's profiles to be publicly searchable, by search engines like Google and Yahoo, and by those without Facebook accounts. Julie Blank, a 23-year-old, was a longtime member of Facebook during her college years. However, when she entered the workforce, she felt her life was becoming too public. "It was almost overwhelming to know everyone could see what was going on in my life, especially those that I knew on a more professional level," Blank said. "It was becoming a hassle to constantly be monitoring what pictures were up and what information was up on the site. So I decided to discontinue my account."
 
Did We Need to Know That?
John Suler, a professor of psychology at Rider University and author of the online book The Psychology of Cyberspace, thinks the appeal of a site like Facebook isn't strictly the searching-for-friends aspect, but the other Web 2.0 features wrapped around it. "It's like having your own Web page, blog, discussion board, and private messaging system all wrapped up in one." In other words, it gives users all the tools to instantly update their networked friends in a matter of seconds with an easy-to-use interface.
 
"I love that I can post pictures on the site and can share them with my friends and family," Mather said. "We end up sharing things quicker." Mather uses Facebook's Notes function as a pseudo blog to update his friends on interesting news items. He also updates his personal status occasionally to let contacts know what he has been up to.
 
Paul Saarinen, 29, is a fan of Facebook but would rather use a site like Twitter to update those in his community about what's happening in his life. Twitter, a micro-blogging site, allows users to instantaneously update their status for their friends to see. Like Facebook, Twitter started off as child's play but has recently come into the limelight when journalists and presidential candidates started using the site to update the public.
 
On August 2nd, Saarinen posted various messages on Twitter through his Wi-Fi-enabled laptop during the birth of his daughter, including an update informing people that his wife was headed into a C-section, and details of her cervical dilation. These updates were accessible to anyone through Saarinen's Twitter page, and each posting was time-stamped and updated in real time as soon as he hit the Update button on his end. "I primarily use Twitter as a conduit to certain friends," Saarinen said. "I don't expect all my friends or family to sign up with an account to get update notifications, but I can just point them to my page, so they can read what I've been doing."
 
Grohol attributes the desire to electronically update friends and family to a decrease in face-to-face communication, thereby increasing our desire to connect with others through social networks. "The Internet, while perhaps reducing some of that direct face-to-face time, has actually increased our connectedness via these kinds of services."
 
Why are more of the wiser generations joining online communities like Facebook? Find out >>

Advertisers